Resurrection Questions

11/10/19 Resurrection Questions Luke 20: 27-38  Job 19: 23-27a; 2 Thes 2: 1-5,13-17

Once a famous Baptist preacher was speaking to some students at a Christian college. A student asked, “Dr. Marney, would you say a word or two about the resurrection of the dead?” He replied, “I don’t discuss such things with anyone under 30. Look at you all: in the prime of life. Never have you known honest-to-God failure, heartburn, impotency, solid defeat, brick walls or mortality. You’re extremely apt and handsome—white kids who have never in all of your lives been 30 miles from home, or 20 minutes into the New Testament, or more than a mile and a half from a Baptist or Methodist church, or within a thousand miles of any issue that mattered to a kingdom that matters. So, what can you know of a world that makes sense only if Christ is raised?”

When I was ordained, I was 28 years old.  I look back on that now and wonder how the wise older saints in my first congregation put up with me.  What did I know then?  I was 28 and filled with confidence. Oh, I knew how to preach a sermon on resurrection for a funeral or for Easter. I had learned so much in seminary. But I’m afraid my questions about the resurrection were something like those of the Sadducees in our gospel, theoretical.  But it’s life that really teaches us. It is as we live and love and lose that we learn. With open hearts and listening ears we can experience the holy and the mystical.  Like Job it is through the suffering that the truth emerges.  His words ring true because they are grounded in life not theory. “I know that my redeemer lives and stands with me, on my side.”

Christian faith is drawing near to God, holding fast to our Redeemer and living in that hope.  It is not about getting our doctrine perfect. It’s not about having all the answers, saying the right prayers or having correct ideas. Doctrines tend to divide.  Controversies repeatedly split the church. In 1054 the East and West split over ideas of the trinity and remain divided to this day. In the 1600’s the Reformed tradition almost split over something as arcane as supralapsarianism vs. infralapsarianism.  Infant baptism vs. a believer’s baptism has divided us in more recent times. 

During the time of Jesus, it was no different.  There were groups of Jews with different beliefs. The Sadducees were rivals to the Pharisees.  Both groups were opposed to Jesus and his followers.  The Pharisees believed in a resurrection from the dead.  The Sadducees did not. It was the Sadducees who challenged Jesus in our gospel today.  They relied only on the first 5 books of the Torah, Genesis through Deuteronomy.  They were sticklers who were certain their way was the only correct way. Those Sadducees who didn’t believe in the resurrection had a question for Jesus about resurrection. What a trap! And their question revealed just how limited they were to the views of their own time—whose property will the woman be if there is a resurrection, they asked.

Jesus deftly points to what is beyond their limits.  Women won’t be property in the life to come.  Your sights are too small.  God is the God of the living!  It’s the same message Paul preached in Romans:  We do not live to ourselves, and we do not die to ourselves.  If we live, we live to the Lord, and if we die, we die to the Lord; so then, whether we live or whether we die, we are the Lord’s! 

The Christian community in Corinth asked similar questions—what kind of body will we have?  Paul contrasts a physical body and a spiritual body.  He uses and image that speaks of both continuity and discontinuity.  This body the physical one, is like a seed and the spiritual body is like the full-grown plant.  The seed becomes the plant.  But how different the two are. 

Martin Luther was asked about the afterlife—he answered in two ways saying that the afterlife is God’s business, so he didn’t have to worry about it.  He also said that we can know as little about life after death as a baby traveling down the birth canal can know about the world the baby is about to enter. 

This summer I had a powerful experience. We had been staying for a few days in St. Louis, Mo. with Jack and Peggy Sieber.  As we were leaving, I felt lightheaded.  When we got in the car, I measured my heart rate with an app on my phone—it was 189 bpm.  Steve drove me to an urgent care facility just a mile or so away. But the facility had just opened for business. The level of training was inadequate. The nurses didn’t know how to operate the EKG machine, so they called an ambulance.  Finally, after about a half an hour, when my heart rate had been high as 210 the ambulance personnel gave me a drug that stopped my heart momentarily in order to re-set the rhythm.  It didn’t work the first time. They had the patches ready on the crash cart—it was all quite scary.

I looked over the heads of all these medical personnel and met eyes with Steve. It was the day before Mother’s Day. Our kids were expecting us. I was worried about my family. I thought, well, if I die here on the table, Jack and Peggy will help Steve cope with things—and my kids and my parents and my sister will be there for each other. Don’t get me wrong, I didn’t want that to be the end—but at some point, my thoughts shifted to the realization that I’d finally have all my resurrection questions answered.  I’d soon be in the presence of God.  I felt no fear, just excitement.

The next time they gave me a double dose of the drug, I felt weightless, suspended like at the top of a rollercoaster, then felt the blood swooshing through my body. Finally, my heart rate dropped to 145 and I got my first ambulance ride where Jack’s golfing buddy, who is the head of cardiac medicine at St. Luke’s Hospital, met me, conducted a bunch of tests to determine I had not had a heart attack.  He put me on medication to get me safely home.  Two weeks later I had a cardiac ablation procedure and voila—I’m fine.  I know it was much easier for me to be the one on the table than the one standing by watching and worrying.  It was only later that I considered what would have happened if we had been on the highway in the mountainous desert between Durango and the US border.  Life is such a precious gift. God’s marvelous grace holds us through this life and beyond to something we can’t yet know or see.

Ten years ago, our daughter had her fourth open heart surgery. The other 3 operations were when she was an infant, before I was her stepmother.  I went into a real tail-spin in the months of anticipation before her valve replacement. I was afraid all the time. Not about her—my belief in the resurrection was strong. I knew all the way to my core, that God would hold her through death and beyond if she were to die. No, I was afraid for myself and for Steve. How would we possibly cope?

Even when we believe in resurrection we can be overcome by our questions, or by the power of loss, or even by anticipated loss. It was the communion of saints that comforted me in the end. I had seen the church surround those who grieve so many times, I knew that whatever happened, we would be held together by people of faith, uplifted and carried when we couldn’t step forward by ourselves. Theoretical questions about God don’t really matter. Our second lesson points us in the right direction. The church in Thessalonica was apparently worried about ideas about the second coming of Christ. Paul’s letter admonished them to draw eternal comfort and good hope instead of getting distracted with wild ideas.  Comfort for our hearts and strength comes through living in faith, through as Paul says– every good work and word. 

The Sadducees came with a manipulative challenge, seeking to debate an intellectual issue with Jesus. He gave them a long answer that set them back on their heels. Compare that to Martha who came to Jesus full of grief over her brother Lazarus’ death.  To her he said, “I am the resurrection

and the life.  Those who believe in me, even though they die, will live…Do you believe this? 

Martha was ready to receive the blessing that Jesus was proclaiming.  For her it wasn’t just a hypothetical question.  Resurrection is a whole new world. Injustice—where women have no hope, no standing, no safety net unless they are married will pass away.  The age to come will be so much more than that—more than we can even ask for or comprehend.

A major league baseball pitcher was once asked what he thought about his future prospects.  He answered, “The future is like the present, only longer.”  That may be true for baseball, but God’s way in Christ is not just a continuation of the present.  It is a whole new way, beyond our present experience, only known through hope and faith in the living God. We can fiddle around with ideas and theories, we can ask theological questions and read all kinds of books. But in the end resurrection is not an abstract issue.  It is part of a life of discipleship, suffering and hope. 

Job spoke from his heart about his lived experience.  The “friends” who appear to counsel him give him answers—they simplify and explain away his circumstances, unconvincingly.  They couldn’t tolerate the complexity and mystery of his life.  But Job rejected their cut and dried answers.  His confession of faith has to do with connection with God, his trust in the Redeemer who stands with him through it all.

We all have friends like Job’s who seem to have all the answers, and if we’re honest sometimes we fall into that same trap ourselves, the trap of believing we know it all, that there is one absolute answer to life’s dilemmas.  When we are in the valley of the shadow of death, when grief overwhelms us, when we are lying on the table with the crash cart at our side what we need is not an answer, we need God’s own self—the resurrection and the life. Like Job we can say, “I know that my Redeemer lives and that I shall see God who is for me.”  

All Are Welcome

Nov 3, 2019; All are Welcome; Luke 19: 1-10; ICCM; Rebecca Ellenson

It’s crazy how we remember things we learn in song, isn’t it?  For example, I learned today’s gospel story when I was just a wee little girl, to a catchy tune complete with actions.

 “Zacchaeus was a wee little man and a wee little man was he.  He climbed up in a sycamore tree for the Lord he wanted to see.”  But Jesus said, ‘Zacchaeus, you come down from there.  For I’m going to your house today, for I’m going to your house today’.”

 I think we saw a filmstrip in Sunday School that day.  If I close my eyes, I can see the primary colored pictures of the little man with his robe hiked up over his knees, awkwardly perched in a tree.  Perhaps it made a big impression on me because I was a wee little girl, and little for my age.

One of the things I love about the stories of Jesus is that they are accessible enough for a wee little girl to grasp, yet deep enough for that same person to keep studying for decades and still find new layers of meaning. On the surface level, this story is about Jesus who clearly sees yet another person who was labeled and scorned by others.  We get to see the wee little man’s joy at being drawn close to Jesus. And we are given an example of what wealth can do when given for the needs of others. 

There’s so much detail in this story:  Zacchaeus is a chief tax collector. He isn’t well liked by the other Jews because he works for the occupying Roman government.  The people assume Zacchaeus is corrupt.  It was common practice for tax collectors to take a surplus amount for themselves, over and above what the government required.  The scene as described is comical — wealth and power don’t stop the important man in the big and important city of Jericho from scrambling up a tree in order to see Jesus as he passes by.  The people have yet another reason to roll their eyes or dismiss Zacchaeus.  What an undignified picture he must have been, perched in a sycamore, or a black mulberry tree!  My good friend Peter has a mulberry tree in his backyard—it’s a messy tree with squishy berries that stain your clothes and fingers. 

Jesus zeroes right in on this wee little man, calling him by name (ironically, Zacchaeus means righteous or clean, even though his association with the Romans and money would have meant people would consider him unclean and suspect, not to mention covered in mulberry stains!)  Jesus tells him to get down from the tree and declares that he must stay at Zacchaeus’ house that day.  The crowd grumbles and identifies the tax collector as a sinner.  Then we learn that, to everyone’s surprise, except Jesus, this man is not what he seems to be.  No, he gives half of his income to the poor and repays 4-fold any overcollection.  Jesus addresses Zacchaeus when he says, “Today salvation has come to this house, because he too is a son of Abraham.  For the Son of Man came to seek out and to save the lost.” 

If we stop at the face value of this story, as we did when we learned that song as children, it is a good and memorable lesson with value.  But as I said before, there’s so much rich depth in the scriptures.  With just a little analysis and digging we discover even more truth.  Don’t you just love that!? We can study the Word all our lives.  We keep learning new things.  We can find salvation anew.  We can encounter the Christ and be led to live lives of joyful and expanding generosity.

Let me explain what I mean by that.  We often just focus on one story of the gospels at a time.  Rarely do we look at how that story fits into the whole of the writer’s narrative.  When we do, though, we see how masterful these scriptures are.  There are layers of meaning when we look for the patterns the writers used to tell the stories of Jesus.  You see, this story about Zacchaeus does not appear in any of the other gospels.  It comes at the end of a section in Luke’s gospel called the travel narrative and it fits into a progression of 10 meals that frame a key message or theme of this gospel about the Lord’s Supper.  Luke composed the gospel and the Acts of the Apostles after Mark wrote his gospel.  He chooses what stories to include and arranges them with cares. 

When Luke wrote the stories of Zacchaeus and the other meals in the gospel, it was more than 50 years since Jesus gathered with his disciples in that upper room the night before he died. Many things had changed, Pilate, Herod, the apostles and even Peter were long gone.  Jerusalem and the temple had been ruined.  But throughout the world of Paul in what is now Syria, Turkey, Greece, and Cyprus Christians gathered each Sunday to do what Jesus did on the night of his last supper.  They took bread, gave thanks, broke it and gave it to each other saying, This is my body which is given for you.  They ate supper together and then afterwards they took the cup and drank proclaiming, This is the cup of the new covenant, for the forgiveness of sins.  The blood symbolized life, connection to Christ who rose.  The bread symbolized their union in one body, offered like Jesus, for the life of the world. 

Luke’s gospel includes 10 meals, seven are part of the travel narrative.  The first is at the house of Levi, an ordinary tax collector.  And today’s meal is the 7th meal, this time at the home of a chief tax collector, Zacchaeus.  These two stories at the homes of the tax collectors frame the other five meals in Luke’s travel narrative.  Levi, the first tax collector is called to follow Jesus right after the call of the first disciples, Peter James and John.  Jesus saw him sitting at the customs post, something like a toll booth today. He said to him, “follow me.” And just like Peter James and John, Levi left everything behind he got up and followed.  Levi then gave a great banquet for Jesus.  A large crowd of tax collectors and others were there at table with them.  The pharisees and scribes complained, just like the crowds did in our lesson for today.  There in the first meal Luke records, Jesus sets out the theme.  “Those who are healthy do not need a physician, but the sick do.  I have not come to call the righteous to repentance but sinners.” 

The second meal takes place at the house of Simon the Pharisee. Do you suppose that the pharisees who didn’t like it that Jesus dined at Levi’s house decided to plan their own dinner for Jesus, to do it right?  Well into that grand symposium style banquet comes a sinful woman who places herself at Jesus’ feet, in the position of a disciple, and wipes Jesus’ feet with her hair and bathes them with a costly ointment.  Simon the pharisee is indignant. Jesus turns to the Pharisee and tells a story about two people whose debts were forgiven, one small one large.  He then contrasts the welcome Simon and the woman offered Jesus.  Like Simon, we and all those who hear these words are drawn in.  All are welcome, especially those whose sins are great. True worship, as Isaiah foretold, comes from repentance, forgiveness, reconciliation and finally an outpouring of love.  Jesus concludes his teaching with these words: “So I tell you, her many sins have been forgiven; hence, she has shown great love.  But the one to whom little is forgiven, loves little.”

Luke’s next meal is the feeding of the multitude in Bethsaida with the meager loaves and fishes.  In this meal Jesus himself is the host.  He blesses the bread, breaks them, and gives them to his disciples who set them before the crowd.  And all eat and are satisfied and 12 baskets of leftovers are gathered up. 

The next meal is at the home of Mary and Martha where another woman sits at Jesus’ feet as a disciple.  Then Jesus reclines at the table at another Pharisee’s house where the teachers scold him for not observing all the expected rituals.  The sequence escalates at the home of a leading Pharisee where Jesus tells the story of the beggar Lazarus at the gate of the rich man. 

I’m afraid this service would be as long as a Mexican service if I fully explain how all these meals relate to this central practice of the Christian faith—holy communion.  You’ll have to read the whole gospel, for yourself, paying attention to these meals. For now, you can take my word for it that each meal turns the people’s expectations upside down.  Jesus welcomes everyone, includes everyone, and challenges each of us to do the same.  When people eat with Jesus, they are either transformed by his generosity with acts of discipleship themselves, or they resist Jesus’ extravagant grace, and by doing so exclude themselves from his welcome table. 

It’s not just in the meal stories, though, that Luke pounds this theme home.  Jesus welcomes sinners and he tells stories about the sick and the lost and the overlooked.  The stories of the lost sheep, the lost coin, and the lost prodigal son end with the very same words as our gospel for today:  “The son of man has come to seek and to save that which is lost.”

There is a red thread that runs through the whole fabric of the scriptures.  There is a movement through the centuries toward wholeness, a spiral of truth through each generation, each family, each life, each person, each community of faith from exclusion to inclusion, from uptight legalism to extravagant grace and joyful response, from rigid ceremony and sacrifice to justice and peace. 

I recently came across a poster created by Bixby Knolls United Church of Christ.  I think it fits in very well with the message of our gospel.

The poster reads like this. 

THE BIBLE IS CLEAR: Moabites are bad.  They were not to be allowed to dwell among God’s people (Dt. 23).  BUT THEN comes the story of “Ruth the Moabite,” which challenges the prejudice against Moabites.

THE BIBLE IS CLEAR:  People from Uz are evil (Jer.25).  BUT THEN comes the story of Job, a man from Uz who was the “most blameless man on earth.” 

THE BIBLE IS CLEAR:  No foreigners or eunuchs allowed. (Dt. 23) BUT THEN come the story of an African eunuch welcomed into the church (Acts 8).

THE BIBLE IS CLEAR:  God’s people hated Samaritans.  BUT THEN Jesus tells a story that shows not all Samaritans were bad. 

THE STORY MAY BEGIN with prejudice, discrimination, & animosity but the Spirit moves God’s people toward openness, welcome, inclusion, acceptance, & affirmation.

We started out today with a wee little song about a wee little man, and we’ve dug deep into the structure of Luke’s gospel and even a bit into the long historic arc of scripture that bends toward repentance, forgiveness and reconciliation.  As we come to the table of our Lord, we, like all those he encountered on his journeys to Jerusalem, are invited to take and eat, to be transformed, to be found. And we are sent out from here to reach with open arms, to welcome and invite others into this grace we know. 

Do This

July 14, 2019, Siren and Lewis UMC, Pastor Rebecca Ellenson, “Do This!”

I’m happy to be the guest preacher here, today.  My husband Steve and I attend worship in Webster during the summer months.  I’m a pastor with a part time position for part of the year.  I serve a congregation in Mazatlán, Mexico each winter.  A Mexican Congregational church there opens their doors to the community of snowbirds from the US and Canada. They’ve called me to preach in English to about 150 people from a variety of denominations and locations.  It’s a terrific call for me and I feel very blessed.

When I tell people that we live in Mexico for six months each year the nearly universal response is– “Oh aren’t you afraid?”  Of course, there are dangerous places in Mexico and since Mazatlán is a city of about 700,000 people we exercise the same kind of caution we would in any urban center. One difference is that we don’t drive at night.  It’s not because there are bandits on the roads, like there were in the gospel for today.  It’s because the grazing land is open range and if you hit a farm animal you go to jail until the farmer has been paid damage.

We feel quite safe. In fact, we’ve found the Mexican people to be extremely helpful, welcoming, and generous.  We love participating in outreach and service work when we are there.  One of our favorite projects is a mobile medical/dental/and optical clinic the Mexican congregation operates each year in a very poor area of the city.  We sterilize equipment, hold lights for the dentists, or fit people with reading glasses.  But the most remarkable parts of our experiences there have to do with the generosity and sincere welcome we feel from the Mexican people. 

Mazatlán is host to one of the biggest Mardi-Gras festivals in the world, they call it Carnaval.  The week before Ash Wednesday is a blowout celebration of epic proportions. We live on the parade route.  Last year, on the Sunday before Ash Wednesday the floats were lined up along the ocean.  I had a terrible cold and should have stayed inside, but it was a nice afternoon, sunny and about 70 degrees when we left the apartment.  We wandered up the street to watch the dancers, the marchers, the bands, and the floats as they prepared.  We found a spot just off the sidewalk in front of a traveling vendor who was selling, among other things, coffee cups that featured naked ladies. 

By this time the sun was setting, the wind had picked up, and it had cooled off a bit.  It was elbow to elbow, standing room only.  As the parade started to move, I had a coughing spell.  The vendor scowled at Steve and said to me in Spanish, “You are sick, you should have a coat on!”  I was wearing capri’s and a lightweight tunic-like top.  I assured him I was fine and turned back to watch the parade.  Before long I started coughing again.  Then, the vendor removed his coat, took off his button-down canvas shirt, put his coat back on over his tee shirt layer and handed me his shirt.  “This is clean, take it.  Put it on,” he insisted with another scowl at my clearly negligent husband.  After another 5 minutes or so we decided to leave.  I tried to give him back his shirt but he smiled a gap-toothed gentle smile at me and said, “No, it’s yours.  God bless you!”  I have to say it’s the only time a stranger has given me the shirt off his back.  

A good Samaritan is a stranger who helps a person in need.  In our story the Samaritan is the one who SEES the need, DRAWS NEAR, is MOVED WITH COMPASSION, and ACTS on behalf of the other. 

We’re conditioned to be wary aren’t we, to fear the stranger, to protect ourselves.  What happens when we encounter someone stranded, injured, or in need?  One time, many summers ago, I was driving back to Duluth from my parents’ lake home with my two kids.  They were about 4 and 9 years old I suppose.  My daughter Cora was strapped into her booster seat in the backseat of our SUV.  It was dusk, about this time of year.  I’m sure it was after 9 pm and she wanted me to recline her seat.  So, I pulled over to the side of highway 210, near Motley MN.  I went around to the rear passenger side door and was kneeling on the seat, one knee on either side or her legs, awkwardly reaching over her to recline the seat. 

Suddenly, out of nowhere it seemed, a great big man dressed in a sleeveless tee shirt and gym shorts appeared in the open doorway, just an arms-length from me.  He smelled of sweat and alcohol and asked me in a slurred and smarmy voice if I needed help.  I said no, and he stepped in closer.  I was a woman alone on the roadside with my children.  I was also a red-belt level karate student at the time.  Without even thinking, I chambered my left fist to my waist, ready to defend us if I needed too.  Just then our little dog, a Brittany spaniel, stepped right over Cora between us, growling at the man.  He backed away and I pulled the door shut and locked it, crawling over the front seat and peeling out onto the highway. 

A few miles down the road, my son Peter said to me, “That was really scary mom.”  My son was also a karate student and he bravely told me that he would have side kicked the man if he had been in my place.  I said, “Well, Peter, I was kneeling so I couldn’t do that.  I thought a palm heel strike to his face would work, though.”  Later on, when we’d calmed down and I had time to think about it I considered what could have happened, what the newspaper headlines might have read: “Pastor attacks Good Samaritan by the roadside.” 

As Luke tells the story, an expert in Jewish Law asks Jesus a testing question, “What must I do to inherit eternal life?”  I don’t think it was a “how do I get to go to heaven when I die?” question.  He wanted to know the true meaning of life, how to live fully. 

Jesus turned the question back to the questioner.  “What is written, how do you read?”  The lawyer gave the correct answer.  “You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart, with all your soul, with all your strength, and with all your mind, and you shall love your neighbor as yourself.”  Good answer Jesus said, “Do this, and you will live.”

But the lawyer wanted more clarification.  I think the real question he was asking is “Who is Not my neighbor?  How much love are we talking about?  Where can I draw the line?  Outside my door? The people I know?  What about those other people? Other cultures, other races, other religions, other denominations, orientations, nationalities, political persuasions?  There’s a limit, right?  Remember, this man is a legal expert.  I bet he’d love to get into a philosophical discussion and talk theoretically.  But no, Jesus keeps it real.  He tells a story

A man was walking down the road from Jerusalem to Jericho when he was attacked by bandits.  They robbed, beat, stripped, and left him for dead.  Soon afterwards, a priest came by.  Seeing the wounded man, he passed by on the other side of the road.  A short while later, a Levite did likewise.  But then a Samaritan came along.  Seeing the stranded victim, he drew close, and felt deep compassion.  He bandaged the man’s wounds, annointed them with oil and wine, carried him to the nearest inn on his own animal, paid the innkeeper for the victim’s further care, and promised to return with more money as needed.

“So.  Which of the three was a neighbor to the man who was robbed?” Jesus asked.  “The one who showed him mercy,” the lawyer replied.  “Go and do likewise,” Jesus said again.  “Do this and you will live.”

Be like the Samaritan, not the Priest or the Levite, right?  It may not be easy, but at least it’s clear.  Do this.  See the one in need. Draw close.  Feel with compassion. Show mercy.  Extend kindness.  Live out your theology in hands-on care for other people.  Don’t just think love.  Do it. 

DebieThomas writes on a blog called “Journey With Jesus,” on the texts for the Sundays of the church year.  She suggests that as is so often true with Jesus and his stories, just when we think we’ve got it all figured out, a morality story about serving others, there’s more to it than the surface level.  It is more than just a “be good and generous” story. 

You see, when Jesus told this story, the hatred between the Jews and the Samaritans was ancient, entrenched, and bitter. The two groups disagreed about everything that mattered: how to honor God, how to interpret the Scriptures, and where to worship.  They practiced their faith in separate temples, read different versions of the Torah, and avoided social contact with each other whenever possible. Though we’re inclined to see the Good Samaritan as the ideal, Jesus’ choice of this particular hero was nothing less than shocking to first century ears. 

After all, he was the Other.  The enemy of the Jews.  The object of their fear, their condescension, their disgust, and their judgment.  He was the heretical outcast.  To get the point today we might ask ourselves: Who is the last person on earth you’d ever want to deem “a good guy?”  The last person you’d ask to save your life?  Whom do you secretly hope to convert, fix, impress, control, or save — but never, ever need?  A Mexican naked-lady-cup vendor?  A disheveled but strong looking man who smells of sweat and alcohol on a rural MN highway? For the modern Israeli Jewish man it might be a Good Hamas member.  Let’s say a liberal Democrat is robbed, and a Good conservative Republican saves her life.  A white supremacist is robbed, and a Good black teenager saves his life.  A transgender woman is robbed, and a Good anti-LGBTQ activist saves her life. An atheist is robbed, and a Good Christian fundamentalist saves his life.     

Every time and place has agonizing differences that divide us. Those divisions are real, not theoretical, they are not easily negotiated; each side is fully convinced that the other is wrong. What Jesus did when he deemed the Samaritan “good” was radical and risky.  No doubt it stunned his Jewish listeners. He was asking them to dream of a different kind of kingdom.  He was inviting them to consider the possibility that a person might add up to more than the sum of her political, racial, cultural, and economic identities.  He was calling them to put aside the history they knew, and the prejudices they nursed.  He was asking them to leave room for divine and world-altering surprises.         

Instead of identifying with the potential helpers on the road, what happens if we identify with the wounded, dying man on the road. When we put ourselves in the place of the broken one, grateful to anyone at all who will show us mercy — only then can we feel the unbounded compassion of the Good Samaritan. All divisions fall away on the broken road, out of necessity.  When you’re lying bloody in a ditch, what matters is not whose help you’d prefer, whose way of practicing Christianity you like best, whose politics you agree with.  What matters is whether or not anyone will stop to show you mercy before you die.

The brokenness happens in all sorts of ways.  It may be in a hospital room, or at a graveside, or after a marriage fails, or when a cherished job goes bust. After the storm, the betrayal, the war, the injury, the diagnosis—at those times it won’t be our theology that saves us.  It won’t be our cherished affiliations that matter.  All that matters will be how quickly we swallow our pride and grab hold of whatever hand sees our need, draws near, has compassion and acts on our behalf.

“Who is my neighbor?” the lawyer asked.  Your neighbor is the one who scandalizes you with compassion, Jesus answered.  Your neighbor is the one who upends all the entrenched categories and shocks you with a fresh face of God.  Your neighbor is the one who mercifully steps over the ancient, bloodied line separating “us” from “them,” and teaches you the real meaning of “Good.”

What shall I do to inherit eternal life?  Do this.  Do this and you will live.

Prodigals

March 31, 2019; Prodigal; Rebecca Ellenson; ICCM

There was a man who had two sons…  It is “fiction,” of course. Or at least it is not “the truth” in the ways we are most accustomed to thinking of “truth,” for we are told right up front that Jesus is telling stories now.

And yet, the characters, setting and plot are so familiar to us that it IS real.  And it is TRUE in all the ways that matter. It is a universal story.  It is a story like so many other biblical of other fathers and other sons. Think, for instance, of Isaac and Esau and Jacob.  Remember all those sons of Jacob — especially Joseph — second to the youngest of that clan. And surely, don’t forget David, who was the youngest of seven or eight sons of Jesse.  Again, and again, the Biblical witness offers us stories of fathers and sons.

So when Jesus began, “There was a man who had two sons…” his listeners would have been able to identify quickly with the characters.  And they would have also remembered all those other fathers and all those other sons. They probably expected the drama to play out around the story of the younger son

  • They knew the story of Jacob the younger twin and his need to flee his brother Esau’s wrath after having cheated him out of his birthright. 
  • They were well acquainted with Joseph, the second to the youngest and his tendency to lord his father’s favoritism over his older brothers. 
  • And David was always in their minds, both his profound gifts, and also his profound failures.

As in the parable Jesus told, eventually each of those younger sons found their way back home — either literally or figuratively. And in their returning, each was an example of the power and the grace of God.  The same is true in the story we’re looking at today.

The parable of the man with two sons is told primarily for those who identify with the older son. At the beginning of the chapter we hear the grumbling of the faithful, the Pharisees and the scribes, voicing their distress that “this fellow welcomes sinners and eats with them.”  This story is aimed at all of us who forget it is only because of the power of God at work in the lives of Jacob and Joseph and David, or even our own lives, that any of us may be called ‘righteous.’

I recently read a review of a book, by Jeanne Bishop, titled, Change of Heart:  Justice, Mercy, and Making Peace with my Sister’s Killer.  Bishop draws on our gospel today as a tool for her process of forgiveness and reconciliation.  The author’s story is similar to that of a couple I knew quite well, who lost a child in 1991 in a horrible crime.  My friends, Don and Mary Streufert’s then 18-year-old daughter was brutally murdered by two men.  Don and Mary and their other daughter, Emily, endured an excruciating dialogue process with the two men, guided by a mediator from a restorative justice project of the University of Minnesota. They wanted to express their feelings and get answers to questions unaddressed during the trial.

The Strueferts were members of the church I served in Duluth and Don and I later worked together in an ex-offender re-entry program.  He became an expert at restorative justice and reconciliation, but he didn’t set out to forgive, initially.  But, over time he began to experience something like forgiveness.  It was something happening inside him that had nothing to do with the behavior of the two men.  He says, “seeing our common humanity is a watershed decision. I’m as human as those two men. I’ve come to see there’s a man there. There is care. One of the killers expressed remorse.”

My friends were able to move from profound brokenness to healing. Just like the author, Jeanne Bishop, their journey was rooted in and directed by their faith. In Bishop’s description about her own need for reconciliation, she drew upon the story of the prodigal son. In her first attempt to reach out to the man who murdered her sister she wrote him a letter where she says:

You and I are no different in the eyes of God. I am someone who has fallen short and hurt God’s heart; I have sinned, to use that Biblical word, just as you have. You are a child of God, created in God’s image, just as I am. God loves you every bit as much as me; nothing you have done could ever stop God from loving you. The division I have made between us — you, guilty murderer, me, innocent victims’ family member — was a false divide. I was wrong to do that.  The only thing that could possibly pay for the loss of Nancy, her husband and their baby is this nearly-impossible thing: that you would make your way home to God, the way the Prodigal Son in one of Jesus’ parables finds his way home.

The parallel she draws is not exactly the same, of course. There is no grisly murder in the story Jesus tells. There is, however, profound brokenness in the relationship the two brothers share as the older one feeds his own sense of self-righteousness which has been building for his entire life. Oh yes, his deep resentment appears to have him seeing himself as “fundamentally different from the other.” As better, somehow. As more deserving, more worthy.

The Streuferts and Jeanne Bishop only found any semblance of wholeness again AS they sought to move towards reconciliation with the ones who took so much from them.  I know this was also the case in at least some of the other stories those first listeners must have had echoing in their memories as Jesus spoke.

Think of Joseph’s brothers whose remorse was real enough that they would do all they could to protect their youngest brother Benjamin. And whose lives were not really ‘whole again’ until they were united once more with the brother they had wronged. One could certainly argue that this was doubly the case for Joseph who clearly had nursed his resentment against his older brothers all those years — and who never even made an attempt to be in touch with his aging father.  And think of Esau, who in the end, met his brother, Jacob, on his way home — and welcomed him with open arms.

Indeed, the saddest part of the story Jesus shares today is not that the younger brother had strayed, but that the older brother is allowing himself to remain bound up in his own bitter self-righteousness, in his own resentment. There is profound joy in the story when the younger son finds his way home. Only the father’s joy will not be complete until his older son finds his way home as well. Home to that place where love is the first and final arbiter of all that matters.

Home. Where we are meant to remember that God’s power is at work in all of us. All of us. And where we will only find the wholeness God intends for us when we extend that wholeness to others. Most especially, perhaps, those who have hurt us most of all.

Forgiveness is powerful.  And it is very hard. Today, March 31st, is the hardest day of each year for me.  40 years ago on this date I was deeply hurt by another person.  Each year that has passed I’ve had a sort of trigger reaction. I have worked hard to process the experience.  In the early years I suffered from active PTSD and sought the support of counselors, pastors and support groups.  I’m proud and relieved and grateful when I say that I’ve let go of the fear, and most of the resentment and anger.  But not a year goes by that I don’t feel the residue of an assault that changed the course of my life.  This year, I’m asking myself if I really want the wholeness that comes by recognizing God’s love even for the person whose actions still affect me. 

This familiar parable is incomplete.  We do not know if the older brother ever finds his way inside to the party. If he ever finds his way ‘home.’ I imagine Jesus left the plot dangling right there so that all of us might somehow experience the invitation as well. As Esau did. As Joseph and his brothers did. As Jeanne Bishop and Don and Mary Streufert did. As I am experiencing that invitation yet again. I expect Jesus did not tell us the ending of this parable because we each need to write our own ending, even now.

Who hasn’t heard the prodigal son story a hundred times?  We think we know what it means, but it is so powerful the message in this text.  It pushes us to the limits of understanding God’s grace.  I’m sure each of you have a grudge you’re holding, a hurt you can’t let go of, a place of brokenness that runs deep.  Even our current polarization in political terms encourages us to vilify the other.  So what shall it be?

  • Shall we, set aside own bitter pride and celebrate the God’s who forgiveness knows no bounds?  Shall we go inside, and join the celebration after all? 
  • Will we accept this invitation to wholeness which can only be ours if we recognize God’s love even for those who have hurt us most of all?
  • Or shall we continue to deny the power, the grace, the love of God for the ones we have deemed to be somehow ‘fundamentally different’ from us?
  • Shall we sacrifice our own potential wholeness to prove a point which was never God’s point at all?

Indeed, how will this story end?

Wilderness Journey

As far back as we can imagine, human beings have marked the passing of time using the movement of the sun, the moon and the stars. Kings and Emperors have set the calendars and priests and shamans have designated holy days. The Hebrew people’s calendar goes back as far as the time of the Exile in Babylon, with the New Year, Rosh Hosanna, falling in October.

The early church established festival days and identified seasons leading up to or following those holy days, each with their own mood, color and emphasis. Most Christians follow what is called the liturgical year, a calendar distinct from the secular calendar. Our church year begins not in January but 4 weeks before December 25th. While the rest of the world is singing Christmas carols and partying in December, the church established a counter-cultural tone by observing Advent, a four wee season of hopeful waiting, expectation and preparedness for welcoming Christ into our lives. The season of Christmas in the church is only 12 days long, from Christmas Day to Epiphany, the season that starts with the celebration of the star that led to magi to Jesus and continues until Ash Wednesday, the first day of Lent. Epiphany’s theme is revelation, how we see Christ showing up in the world, and in our lives.

Ash Wednesday is determined by counting back 40 days, not counting Sundays (since every Sunday is a celebration of the resurrection) from Easter. In the year 325 the leaders of the Council of Nicaea decided that Easter would be held on the first Sunday after the first full moon occurring on or after the vernal equinox, which is why Easter isn’t on a set day each year but varies according to the moon. Lent, like advent is supposed to be a time of preparation for the celebration of Jesus’ resurrection. It has often been a time for considering our sinfulness, marked by making sacrifices to remind us of what Jesus gave for us all. It is a time for extra prayer, self-discipline, bible study, service and devotion.

Holy Week starts with what used to be known as Palm Sunday , most often now referred to as the Sunday of the Passion. Maundy Thursday is the day that remembers the last supper and the foot washing, Good Friday focuses on the crucifixion, and of course Easter focuses on the resurrection. The season of Easter examines the post-resurrection appearances of Christ and leads up to Pentecost Sunday when the Holy Spirit descended like a dove in tongues of fire on the early church gathered in Jerusalem. The season between Pentecost and Advent is called Ordinary Time or simply the Sundays after Pentecost. During that long season we get the stories of Jesus’ life and ministry, his parables and teachings.

Ever since its earliest days the church has established a schedule of scripture readings for each Sunday and festival of the church year, based on the seasons. That system of readings is called the lectionary. It is a three year cycle of readings that includes an Old Testament reading, a psalm, a New Testament reading and a gospel text. Year 1 or A has readings from Matthew, Year 2 or B Mark, Year 3 or C Luke and John’s gospel is divided among the three years. The plan is designed to lead worshippers through nearly the entire Bible every 3 years.

Today is the first Sunday in Lent. Every year we hear the story of Jesus’ temptation in the wilderness. This year, year C, we also stand with the ancient Israelites on the edge of the wilderness, looking into the promised land. There is the Jordan River valley, where Jesus’ cousin John will baptize him centuries later and God will name him, and every child of God, as beloved.

Lent invites us to step intentionally into that which is broken and torn, a space in which we learn to be vulnerable again so that we may journey into the very heart of God. We slow our pace during these 40 days because the landscape of Lent takes us through the wildernesses of our own hearts and souls, where we must walk carefully, think deeply, allow our hearts to be broken open, lay bare all that is hidden, buried, or repressed.

Lent is un-apologetically counter-intuitive. It continues the work that Mary sang in the Magnificat of the world turned upside down, where the lowly are lifted up and the mighty are brought down from their thrones. Lent, like Advent, is a turning an overturning, a re-turning. Lent disrupts the conventional wisdom of a world that says we begin in life and end in death.

Many congregations observe Ash Wednesday, a smudgy reminder that death is only the beginning, a cross on a forehead as a declaration to the world of our intention to die to all those things that keep us entombed, pride, avarice, self-doubt, fear, isolation, cynicism and every single other barrier that prevents us from living a wholehearted existence with God. It is a yearly reminder that we are mortal and each moment is precious. The ashes challenge us to be fully human, to acknowledge that life is hard. It comes with unwelcome diagnoses, seemingly insurmountable challenges, impossible decisions, systematic injustice, grief, pain and loss.

The ashes of Lent set the tone for the season and mark our mortality. Yet, we are on a journey of life. We face situations that break our hearts daily, and yet we declare those hearts belong to God. We admit that we have strayed from the pathways of righteousness, even as we profess our repentance and turn toward the good.

Ash Wednesday’s text includes the prophet Joel’s call out across the millennia, “Yet even now, says the Lord, return to me with all your heart, with fasting, with weeping, and with mourning; rend your hearts and not your clothing.”

Rend your hearts! Break them open! Those walls that you have built around your hearts to keep them safe and comfortable shut me out! Those walls block everything that makes you so delightfully and uniquely human! Remember that you are fearfully and wonderfully made! Turn around; come closer; come home,” says our God.

This is the call of Lent. When things seem hopeless, when there is fear and trembling in the land and a day of great darkness descends, and armies are encamped just outside the gates of our well-guarded hearts, that is when the call to return to God becomes most urgent and necessary. The lectionary texts for each week are blessings that God has left us, like a trail of breadcrumbs, that lead us into resurrected lives. Fed and nourished this way, we can endure the wilderness. The heart of all heats will not leave us wandering and directionless. Each Sunday there will be a signpost taht marks another step toward life, toward the rising that takes place once we are brave enough to rend our hearts. There is an old gospel song that we’ll sing next Sunday that suggests an image of God sitting on the porch in a rocking chair waiting for us, wayward children that we are, to find our way home again. Through blessing, breadcrumbs, Scripture and ash, the heart of our God is calling, “Come home. Come home. You who are weary come home; calling O Sinner come home!”

Today’s Old Testament lesson invites us to stand on the edge of the wilderness today, looking over Moses’ shoulder, and Jesus’ shoulder, so to speak. We look ahead into the promised land of life in Christ, of rising with him. The Old Testament text carries a story that the Israelites are asked to repeat over and over as they bring their first fruits to the priest to be blessed. “A wandering Aramean was my ancestor…” the story begins. It is a reminder that even when thy have inhabited the land for such a long time that they come to the Temple with their arms laden with the fruit of their harvest, they never forget to whom the land truly belongs and the story of how they came to be. It is a story that grounds them in a tale of survival and struggle. Even when, perhaps especially when, they begin to get comfortable and are tempted to forget that it is God from whom all blessings flow, they are called to remember. This history called to mind the truth that at some point we have all been hungry, nomadic, rootless, dispossessed, dependent on God and one another for comfort, care, and survival. Maybe not in our own lifetimes, but certainly in the lives of those who came before us.

My own grandma told the story of her journey from Norway to North Dakota, hungry and longing for a small coin to buy an apple from a woman selling the fruit on the train. My grandfather had been sick on the boat across the ocean and shifted from one line at Ellis Island to another, afraid of the officer in the first line who seemed to be scrutinizing the immigrants more closely than the other officers.

The Deuteronomy text ends with a celebration, a feast where those who cannot or do not own the land will feast with those who do! If we look one verse forward we see that the priests, the immigrants, the widows and the orphans are included. This is a journey that ends in all being fed. This is the promised land–heaven come to earth–this is the purpose of remembering this story. When we recall our own vulnerability, our own desert wanderings, then we are more apt to include those on the margins who know too little joy, compassion or kindness.

Powerful things happen when we remember, when we look from the wilderness toward the promises of God. Our hearts as well as our tables become more open, more generous. We recognize the abundance of gifts we have been given is meant to be shared. Suddenly our hearts and our tables begin to look more like God’s heart and Christ’s table. “Do this in remembrance of me,” Christ says. Tell this story, eat this bread, drink this cup share all that you are and all that you have in Christ’s name. Amen.


Full Fragility of Life

March 24, 2019; The Full Fragility of Life;  ICCM; Pastor Rebecca Ellenson

When I do hospital visitation, the calls I dread most are not the ones to the emergency room, or the psychiatric ward, or even the morgue.  The hardest calls come from the pediatric floor or the neo natal unit, where little babies lay in cribs with bandages closing their eyes or where sweet faced children push IV poles down the hall. 

I suppose that is in part due to our own family history. Steve’s youngest daughter was born without a right ventricle and spent her first months in Children’s Hospital in Minneapolis, MN.  She had two open heart operations during her first month of life, another a year later, another at the age of 13 and her most recent surgery was a valve replacement 4 years ago.  That last one wasn’t open heart, instead of cracking her chest open a fifth time, they were able to do a valve replacement via catheter. 

Steve’s brother in law is currently recovering from quadruple bypass surgery and his elder brother is undergoing yet another round of chemotherapy.  He recently wrote the following message in a text group with his siblings who were expressing just how hard their current experiences have been.  Steve’s a great writer and a deep thinker.  He wrote: 

I’ve been asked questions about how I dealt with knowing my child could die in any one of her surgeries.  I answer, “We All Have a Children’s Hospital.” We don’t know when, what or how it will be.  But something that exposes the full fragility of life will happen in each of our lives at some point.  Then and only then do we know who we will deal with the crisis.  But, deal with it me must.  There is no other choice.  A gifted counselor once asked me if I was prepared for my child to die?  Had I faced the very real possibility that she would not survive me?  Through those questions I confronted my unspoken fears and when I did, I knew I was not alone or unique in any way.  This path has been traveled by everyone and will be travelled again and again.  We all share in this walk.  There is no escaping it.  Walk strongly, walk with courage, walk with the love and support of those who surround you.  Find peace and comfort in sharing your burdens and knowing you are not walking alone. 

One of my other favorite writers, Barbara Brown Taylor, writes about her experiences as an Episcopal Priest, visiting the pediatric waiting room.  One day, she received a call to come sit with a mother while her five year old daughter was in surgery.  Earlier in the week, the girl had been playing with a friend when her head began to hurt.  By the time she found her mother, she could no longer see.  At the hospital, a CAT scan confirmed that a large tumor was pressing on the girl’s optic nerve and she was scheduled for surgery as soon as possible. 

On the day of the operation, Barbara found her mother outside the hospital on the smoker’s bench.  She was smoking and smelled as if she had smoked a whole pack right there on that bench.  She was staring at the concrete in front of her with her eyebrows raised in that half-hypnotized look that warned her to move slowly.  She sat down beside her.  The mother came to, and after some small talk she told her just how awful it was.  She even told her why it happened. 

“It’s my punishment,” she said, “for smoking these damned cigarettes.  God couldn’t get my attention any other way, so he made my baby sick.”  Then she started crying so hard that what she said next came out like a siren, “Now I’m supposed to stop, but I can’t stop.  I’m going to kill my own child.”

Barbara Brown Taylor says it was hard for her to hear.  She decided to forego reflective listening and concentrate on remedial theology instead.  “I don’t believe in a God like that,” she said, “The God I know wouldn’t do something like that.”  The only problem with her response was that it messed with the mother’s world view at the very moment she needed it most.  However miserable it made her, she preferred a punishing God to an absent or capricious one.  Barbara may have been able to reconcile a loving God with the daughter’s brain tumor, but at the moment the mother could not.  If there was something wrong with her daughter, then there had to be a reason. She was even willing to be the reason.  At least that way she could get a grip on the catastrophe.

Even those of us who claim to know better react the same way.  Calamity strikes and we wonder what we did wrong.  We scrutinize our behavior, our relationships, our diets, our beliefs.  We hunt for some cause to explain the effect, in hopes that we can stop causing it.  What this tells us is that we are less interested in truth than consequences.  What we crave, above all, is control over the chaos of our lives. 

Luke does not divulge the motive of those who told Jesus about the Galileans whose blood Pilate mingled with their sacrifices.  The implication is that those who died deserved what they got, or at least that is the question Jesus perceives in the background.  “Do you think that because these Galileans suffered in this way they were worse sinners than all the other Galileans?”

It is a tempting equation that solves a lot of problems.  First, it answers the riddle of why bad things happen to good people.  Next it punishes sinners right out in the open as a warning to everyone. And finally, it gives us a God who obeys the laws of physics.  For every action, there is an opposite and equal reaction.  Any questions?

It is a tempting equation, but Jesus won’t go there.  “No,” he tells the crowd, “but unless you repent, you will all perish as they did.”  It’s a sort of giving with one hand and taking away with the other kind of answer.  No, Jesus says, there is no connection between the suffering and the sin.  Whew.  But unless you repent, you are going to lose some blood too.  Oh.

There is no sense in spending too much trying to decipher this piece of the good news. As far as we can tell, it is not meant to aid reason but to disarm it.  In an intervention aimed below his listeners’ heads, Jesus touches the panic they have inside of them about all the awful things that are happening around them.  They are terrified by those things, for good reason.  They have searched their hearts for any bait that might bring disaster sniffing their way.  They have lain awake at night making lists of their mistakes. 

While Jesus does not honor their illusion that they can protect themselves in this way, he does seem to honor the vulnerability that their fright has opened up in them.  It is not a bad thing for them to feel the full fragility of their lives.  It is not a bad thing for them to count their breaths in the dark, not if it makes them turn toward the light. 

It is that turning that he wants for them, which is why he tweaks their fear.  Don’t worry about Pilate and all the other things that can come crashing down upon your heads, he tells them.  Terrible things happen, and you are not always to blame.  But don’t let that stop you from doing what you are doing.  That torn place your fear has opened up inside of you is a holy place.  Look around while you are there.  Pay attention to what you feel.  It may hurt you to stay there and it may hurt you to see, but it is not the kind of hurt that leads to death.  It is the kind that leads to life.

Depending on what you want from God, this may not sound like good news to you.  I doubt it would have sounded like good news to the mother on the smoking bench outside the hospital.  We all have a Children’s Hospital like experience that pushes us to our deepest fears, where we face our mortality or that of our closest loved ones, or where we push through the depths of despair or injustice.  It’s the reality we know.  We discover that we cannot make life safe, nor can we make God tame.  The gospel becomes enough, it is all we really have, the presence of God, who knows our suffering, the love of others who help us through. It is a life-giving fear that pushes us to turn our faces to the light.  That way, whatever befalls us, we will fall the right way, into the everlasting grace of God. 

Fox and the Hen

Fox and Hen; Luke 13; March 17, 2019; Pastor Rebecca Ellenson; ICCM

Have you seen the movie Braveheart?  It’s an old movie with Mel Gibson playing William Wallace, a Scottish clan leader who inspired and led a revolution against English rule.  This Scottish uprising for freedom took place at the end of the 1200’s.  The movie is filled with lots of bloody combat scenes and takes plenty of historical liberties.  As the story unfolds in the movie, Wallace has many chances to accept a settlement from the English Crown, to trade his power with the people for personal ease, to exchange his conviction for prestige and wealth.  Over and over he holds true to his purpose and determination.

Even when he is betrayed by a man he trusted, he does not lose heart or give up.  At one point, just before being drawn and quartered he is offered a drug to ease the pain of his impending death.  His refusal of the drug that would dull his wits comes with the words, “every man must die, not every man truly lives.”  He stays true to his goal, unwilling to compromise, to weaken, to recant—even when to do so would save his life or ease his own suffering.  He was determined to win freedom for Scotland even until his last breath.

I’ve seen the movie several times, and whenever I see it, I think about Jesus, who showed unwavering determination all through his life.  Jesus had numerous chances to soften his tone, to compromise, to save himself.  But to do that would have been untrue to his purpose.

Today’s gospel is one of those times when it might have been strategically wise to soften his tone, but he didn’t.  Some Pharisees came to warn Jesus that Herod was out to kill him, that he should leave Galilee.  It was no idle threat.  Herod’s power was great.  It was Herod who had first imprisoned John the Baptist, and then had him beheaded.  Yet Jesus didn’t waver, even when threatened with the power of the king.  It’s as if Jesus was saying:

Herod’s power is not final. Go tell that fox I have work to do.  Herod may think he’s a lion, but he’s a crafty little fox and I’ve got more important things to do than focus on a threat to my own safety.  Self-preservation is not the issue.  I’ll be casting out demons and healing today, tomorrow, and the next day until I have accomplished what I need to accomplish. Then I’ll go to Jerusalem, they can kill me there, as is fitting.

Jesus knows his purpose is to love with the protectiveness of a mother hen.  Threats and rejection are not enough to stop him.  He won’t retreat or shortcut or settle for half truths or half measures.  He heads right into the center of the conflict, right to the central city, Jerusalem. 

In many ways this passage is about a conflict of wills.  We have four wills to consider here: 

  • Herod’s will to get rid of Jesus
  • Jesus’ determination to stick to his purpose
  • Jerusalem’s unwillingness to receive the prophets of God, including Jesus
  • And God’s own will to save humanity.

This passage is about God’s passionate determination to save and human determination to resist that salvation.  It is about the intensity of God’s wanting to give us mercy, God’s unceasing desire to gather us like a hen under her wings because God sees what our life is life and what it would be like without God.

God’s will is the one that wins in this contest of wills.  Jesus is obedient to go and do what God wills alone, not what anyone else dictates.  That will includes going to Jerusalem. Jesus repeats that will in Luke 18:31 when he takes the 12 aside and says to them, “See, we are going up to Jerusalem, and everything that is written about the Son of Man by the prophets will be accomplished.” 

Luke uses Jerusalem as a structure for the central part of the gospel.  In Chapter 9: 51 Jesus “sets his face toward Jerusalem.”  In chapter 19: 41-44 he laments over Jerusalem one more time, he says,

If you, even you, had only recognized on this day the things that make for peace! But now they are hidden from your eyes.  Indeed, the days will come upon you, when your enemies will set up ramparts around you and surround you and hem you in on every side.  They will crush you to the ground, you and your children within you, and they will not leave within you one stone upon another; because you did not recognize the time of your visitation from God. 

Then after those fire-y words of prediction he goes on to cleanse the temple.

In between setting his face to Jerusalem in chapter 9 and cleansing the temple in chapter 19 we have this long journey to the city with repeated reminders along the way that this path to Jerusalem is God’s will and has to do with saving the world.  Our text today stands at the midway point in the journey.  It is both a reminder that this determined messiah cannot be sidetracked or made to compromise his purpose and a prophetic sign that Jesus is aware that resistance and rejection are part of God’s saving purpose, resistance that pushes him all the way to the cross.  Here, midway to the cross, we see our savior, caught up in the passion, love, judgment and struggle of wills.  We see a savior who knows his function is to love with the protectiveness of a mother hen, no matter what threats or rejection stand in the way. 

Ok—let’s pause here and explore the images.  Herod is a fox and Jesus is a mother hen.  What does that mean?  Not many people have much exposure to mother hens these days.  Steve and I had laying hens when we lived in Duluth, but without a rooster the eggs weren’t fertile and those hens didn’t get to brood over their eggs or any chicks.  Some of you may have raised brooder chicks with lamps and feeders and heaters and such.  We see the occasional chicken on the back streets here in Mazatlan, but the days of mother hens as a common image are almost gone. 

A friend of mine was raised on a farm.  Her mother raised hundreds of chicks for butcher in a brooder house, and they had laying hens too, but they had roosters too and each year they would let the hens brood over a nest of eggs, one nest for each of the kids in the family. My friend and her siblings were responsible to raise those chicks to maturity.  When they sold the grownup chickens, then the money went to pay for books or toys or special clothes.  She told me that to see a mother hen was a heartwarming sight.  The mother hen would cluck to call her chicks and they would come running.  She would stand with wings outspread and when they were all tucked in close, she would fold her wings over them, hiding them completely from sight, protecting them from whatever dangers were there.

Another friend of mine, Pastor John Sippola, once told me a story about just how protective hens are.  John’s uncle was a farmer and had a hen house, like many farmers did. One night the hen house caught on fire.  They were unable to put the fire out.  The next morning John’s uncle was out surveying the damage, kicking around in the ashes.  He came up to the charred body of a hen and lightly nudged it over.  Underneath were live chicks.

Jesus loves us with the love of a mother hen.  That’s no soft image.  It is determined and protective.  1st John puts it this way,

God is love.  God’s love was revealed among us in this way:  God sent the Son into the world so that we might live through him.  In this is love, not that we loved God but that God loves us and sent the Son…Beloved, since God loves us so much, we also ought to love one another.  No one has ever seen God; if we love one another, God lives in us and God’s love is perfected in us.

This is what we need to know.  God is love.  Jesus Christ shows that love, so we can live it.  Nothing need stand in the way of that love.  Jesus showed us that.  Not threats by kings, not desertion by closest friends, not hanging on a cross, not death or burial.  The last word is love that rises from the ashes of death.  There is a harsh intensity to God’s love.  God will give it all for the love of us. 

Thy Holy Wings, O Savior, spread gently over me, O close thy wings around me, and keep me safely there, enfold us, one and all.  Amen.

Checking In

Good Morning! Steve and I are back from a lovely week-long trip to the Mexican state of Colima. We went with our good friends Karen and Dave to escape the noise and commotion of Carnaval in Mazatlan. We hiked up the side of the most active volcano in Mexico, kayaked in a caldera, went bird watching at dawn, and explored the sleepy town of Comala.

I posted a bunch of sermons today, having fallen WAY behind in my blogging. Sorry about the delay for those of you who look for these weekly. I’ll do better! Thanks for reading.

What Goes Around, Comes Around

What Goes around Comes Around; February 24, 2019; Pastor Rebecca Ellenson; ICCM

There’s a scientific law called Newton’s third law of motion.  It goes: “For every action there is an equal and opposite reaction”?  Or maybe you’ve heard another version of that idea—What goes around comes around. 

It’s true in science and it’s also true when it comes to human relationships, isn’t it?  Our choices have consequences, and sometimes those consequences outlive us.   We see that in the lives of the families written about in Genesis.  Today’s reading comes at the end of a four generation saga. We often focus on just an isolated story from Genesis.  If you haven’t ever read through the whole epic journey of Abraham’s family I encourage you to do so.  There is a lesson about God’s grace and the option of forgiveness that runs through chapters 12-50 of Genesis like a red thread through the fabric of this great book. The characters are true to life—not like superheroes of faith, but men and women riddled with self-doubt, trickery and scheming. The repercussions of their bad choices ripple out, again and again, over generations and finally it is grace and mercy that carries the day.

For those of us who think our families are dysfunctional, well, these families make yours and mine look rather normal, if not downright boring.   Just think about the wild ride they’ve all been on:

  • Abram claimed that his wife Sarah was his sister because he could tell the king of Egypt was interested in her, and Abraham was scared he’d be killed.  Nice
  • Sarah convinced Abraham to have a child with her slave, Hagar, then tried to kill both Hagar and the child when she got jealous. 
  • Abraham almost sacrificed his son Isaac on an altar. 
  • Isaac and his wife Rebekah raised two sons Esau and Jacob, each the favorite of one of their parents.  Their sibling rivalry was extreme, a matter of life and death.  After tricking his brother Esau out of his inheritance Jacob ran away to his Uncle Laban.
  • Laban lied to him and tricked him out of marrying his true love, Rachel—on his wedding day, no less.  Jacob wound up with two wives and two concubines, 12 sons and a daughter.  He destroys his relationship with his uncle Laban and after a 20-year estrangement from his birth family, Jacob fled once again, this time back to his homeland, hoping his brother Esau wouldn’t kill them all.
  • Esau, remarkably forgave his long lost brother’s deception and betrayal and Jacob was able to return home and raise his big family there. 
  • Rachel, Jacob’s favorite, died while giving birth to Benjamin, leaving Jacob grieving and clinging to her memory through the favoritism to the two boys she bore.

As I said, what goes around comes around.  It’s a fascinating saga—of betrayal and deception and ultimately of forgiveness and the power of grace to transform and restore.

  • Joseph, one of Rachel’s boys, the second to the youngest of the 12 sons of Jacob, had been assigned a sort of supervisory position in the family business, at the tender age of 17.  He was responsible for reporting back on the activities of his brothers—who were busy managing Jacob’s herds and flocks. 
  • To make matters worse, Jacob had given Joseph a beautiful coat that reminded anyone who saw it, which son had the favor of their father . . . and which ones didn’t.  Day after day, Joseph would come down to the fields and strut up and down, his beautiful coat swinging easily around his ankles, his brothers work clothes drab in comparison.  Then he would hurry back to his father Jacob and report any indiscretions he observed, any questionable behavior he saw in his brothers. Joseph’s behavior, totally encouraged by his father Jacob, was bound to have a ripple effect.
  • And, it did.  Boy, did it ever.  The straw that broke the camel’s back happened one day when Joseph traveled to where his brothers were working and proceeded to tell them about some dreams he had had, dreams about all the brothers out in the fields, binding sheaves of wheat, when suddenly all the brothers’ sheaves bowed down to Joseph’s.  And another dream, about the sun, the moon and 11 stars, all bowing down to Joseph. 

Joseph interpreted those dreams to mean that he was to be in charge.  The meaning of the dreams was obvious to Joseph’s brothers, too, and they were sick of it . . . sick of Jacob’s favoritism, sick of feeling second best, sick of Joseph’s arrogance . . . just sick of the whole situation.

And so the narrative ball keeps rolling; you know what happened.  The brothers plotted to kill Joseph out there in the field one day and throw his body into a pit.  But somebody’s conscience was pricked—Reuben and Judah convinced their brothers to sell Joseph to a passing caravan, to get him far, far away and out of their hair forever.

They staged the whole thing, killed an animal and smeared that beautiful coat with blood. Then they took it back to their father who assumed Joseph was dead.  Jacob’s grief nearly crippled him, he was so devastated by the loss.  Then, life continued, as it always does even in the face of tragedy and violence and pain. The brothers probably felt avenged for a lifetime of favoritism.  But every action has an equal and opposite reaction, and you’d better believe the brothers’ behavior had consequences.

This saga continues with Joseph’s adventures as a slave, then advisor to Pharoah, culminating finally in Joseph’s forgiveness.  God appears in all manner of ways in the stories of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, but here in the Joseph sa story, God is not mentioned.  All we have are the actions and reactions of human beings, trying desperately to live in community, in family, with each other, and not doing too well at all. 

It was unjust and unfair, no matter how you look at it. No one deserved the treatment they got, not Joseph’s brothers, not Joseph, not Jacob.  But, they made choices to address what they experienced as injustice with other acts of injustice or violence. Except for Esau who broke the cycle with his forgiveness, and finally Joseph does the same at the very end of the story.  Newton’s third law of motion operates throughout, as we know by now it always does.  When faced with injustice we have a choice about how to respond.  And remember, every action has an equal and opposite reaction.

 Simon Wiesenthal was a Jew who lived during World War II in an area of Europe that was conquered by Germany. During the war he was forced to live in a ghetto and then sent to a work camp where he faced the possibility of death every day. One day in the work camp, Wiesenthal was summoned by a nurse to hear the dying confessions of an SS Nazi soldier. The soldier asked for forgiveness for the things he had done to the Jewish people; he wanted forgiveness as he was dying because he was afraid that his soul would not be able to rest in eternity unless he was forgiven.

In his book The Sunflower Wiesenthal tells about trying over and over to leave the room because he was so afraid and because he hated Nazis. But he stayed and listened to the dying man out of pity and also because the soldier begged him not to leave. Wiesenthal recognized that the Nazi soldier was showing true repentance but he also knew that the soldier was ignorant, selfish, and a member of the group that had taken away the lives of his friends and family.

Overwhelmed with the heaviness of the decision, Wiesenthal eventually just left the room.  The next day he found out that the soldier had died and left all his things to Wiesenthal; Wiesenthal spent the rest of his life asking the question: “What would you have done?”

The book’s newest edition includes the contributions of many noted Jewish and Christian thinkers who comment on the dilemma Wiesenthal faced.  Most agree that Wiesenthal could not have forgiven that solider on behalf of an entire race of people, but many also note: there’s something powerful in stopping violence and hatred with forgiveness and love. 

Desmond Tutu, who presided over the Truth and Reconciliation Commission in South Africa after Apartheid writes of Wiesenthal’s dilemma: “It’s clear that if we look only toward a retributive justice, we might as well close up shop.  Forgiveness is not some nebulous thing.  It is practical politics.  Without forgiveness, there is no future.”

Often, things happen to us that we can’t control, the same things that happened then: infertility, political oppression, famine.  Or it may be that we set out, like Jacob, expecting to marry Rachel and end up married to Leah, or we are betrayed by our brothers.  But even when these things happen, we always—always—have a choice about how we will respond to the situations in which we find ourselves.

We can respond to the injustice we face with anger, hatred and violence.  Maybe some would say a response like that is even justified.  But remember: every action has an equal and opposite reaction, and violence and pain and injustice always . . . always . . . breed more violence and pain and injustice. 

What pain could have been avoided if Joseph’s brothers were able to face the unjust situation in which they found themselves and respond, not with violence, but with forgiveness? What if someone had said “I’m sorry?” “Forgive me.”

What pain could we avoid if we train our hearts with the discipline of answering injustice with forgiveness and love? Today – each day – we make choices, like Jacob and Joseph, that impact our lives and the lives of others. What choices will you make? Will you invite God into the process? Choose wisely, dear friends, choose wisely.

Let us pray:  O Gracious One, help us to do to others as we would have them do to us, to love our enemies, do good to those who hate us, bless those who curse us, pray for those who abuse us.  Help us to be merciful, as you are.  You tell us not to judge, lest we be judged, to forgive and we will be forgiven, to give and it will be given to us, a good measure, pressed down, shaken together, running over, for the measure we give will be the measure we get back.  Amen.

Blessed

Blessed; ICCM 2.17.19;  Psalm 1; Pastor Rebecca Ellenson

I think that I shall never see, A poem lovely as a tree.

A tree whose hungry mouth is prest, Against the earth’s sweet flowing breast;

A tree that looks at God all day, And lifts her leafy arms to pray;

A tree that may in Summer wear, A nest of robins in her hair;

Upon whose bosom snow has lain; Who intimately lives with rain.

Poems are made by fools like me, But only God can make a tree.

My Grandma Rustad taught me that poem when I was a little girl.  It leads my thoughts right into Psalm 1.  Grandma gave me my love of poetry and compelled me to memorize scriptures.  My sister Betsy and I spent a part of a week with her and my Grandpa many summers.  Each evening after supper we would go for a walk around the little town of Nevis, MN.  Grandma would point out the wildflowers and the birds, naming each one.  For her, Joyce Kilmar’s poem led right into Psalm 1.  We learned them both as we walked together.

Blessed is the one who walks not in the counsel of the wicked,
nor stands in the way of sinners, nor sits in the seat of scoffers;
but whose delight is in the law of the Lord, and on the law meditates day and night.
like a tree planted by streams of water, that yields its fruit in its season, whose leaf does not wither.

Like all good poetry, we are left with an image to hold onto here—to be blessed is to be like a fruitful tree, planted by the water, with shiny healthy leaves. 

At the end of worship today I will once again invite you to receive the benediction.  I will raise my hands like this, and I will use scriptural words to pronounce God’s blessing on this congregation.  Today those words will come from two of our appointed texts, Jeremiah 17: 8 and Psalm 1: 1 and 6

May you be like trees planted by water who yield your fruit in its season, watched over and protected by God. 

I have lived nearly all my life in Minnesota—our trees are oaks, maples, elms, birches, tamaracks, white pines.  Right now, the landscape there is monochromatic—whites and greys, hints of blue.  The trees stand bare against the vast grey skyline, waiting for spring.  Even the trees planted by the streams are just stark reminders of the light and warmth that will return. 

The trees here are certainly different, probably more like the trees the psalmist referred to.  The evergreens of this climate are the palms and cacti.  I noticed the other day a Guanacaste tree’s new season’s leaves emerging and the elephant ear shaped pods growing shiny and strong on the huge arching branches.  Soon the Jacaranda trees will reach over the buildings with their glorious purple flowers. 

Trees are indicators of life. Their seasonal changes mimic our own patterns. They lift their leafy up; they send roots down deep into the soil. They are both grounded and growing, stationary and on the move. They stretch, they reach, they seek what gives them life—water, soil, and sun.

Nature teaches us. It is the first expression of God, remember—let there be light and life, and fruit bearing trees.  All of creation is connected in the Creator in ways we’re still learning about.  Scientists recently discovered how trees are connected to each other and can communicate and transmit chemicals between them through the web of fungal connections called mycelium. Wow!

The love of God is revealed in all that God has infused with life. So, it should not surprise us that images of trees, shrubs, water, and earth appear throughout our scriptures. These images are of God and of God’s blessed relationship with us. 

In our Gospel, Jesus preaches the Beatitudes in his Sermon on the Plain. For each present reality—poverty, hunger, weeping, hatred—Jesus offers a promise that is to come. The poor will reap the kingdom, the hungry will be filled, the ones who weep will laugh, and the ones who are excluded will leap for joy. There is promise of immediate change, though.  Even those who are right there in Jesus’ presence and hear his words the moment he speaks them are promised gifts of life and joy to come, but not that very day.

Jeremiah 17 and Psalm 1 paint a similar picture. The green, fruit-bearing tree shall be our hope and future. That tree shall not fear when heat comes, and its leaves shall stay green. Even in darkness and drought, the tree shall grow. Even when everything around it tries to take away its life, be that desert heat or bitter cold, the tree shall not die. In the Lord’s care, the tree will live.

It is not the future we trust in though; it is God. We don’t trust in ourselves. We trust in the God who blesses us through our troubled present and leads us to the other side—to a future of hope. When we despair, we hope in God who holds the past, present, and the future—God who knows the poor, the hungry, the weeping, the hated, the excluded, the defamed. God who keeps promises.

But that’s not the end of the passage is it?  At the end of the Sermon on the Plain, Jesus continues to speak of a future—but this time, a future of woe for those who are rich, who are full, who are laughing now. Their promised future shall be filled with sorrow and emptiness. It’s an uncomfortable, even scathing promise. In Jeremiah, those whose hearts turn away from the Lord “shall be like a shrub in the desert,” parched and alone in the wilderness. The other side of the blessing is woe. The other side of promised hope is the reality of lived suffering and despair.

We inevitably live in both conditions—trusting in God or trusting in ourselves. Hungry and full, weeping and laughing, hated and loved. Jesus reminds us that when we are full, we can be sure that we will one day be empty again, and that the only true fullness that endures is from God. When we are weeping, we can be sure that we will one day laugh and rejoice, and that our joy is from God. For every part of life, there is another time that God holds before us, ensuring that we do not forget God’s presence and power infused in everything we do and through everything we live.

As the changing seasons remind us, God’s promise is that there is always another experience and always a reason to hope. It is winter, even here, and spring will come.  I close with one of my favorite scriptures, this time from the Living Bible translation. 

Ephesians 3:17-19 

17 And I pray that Christ will be more and more at home in your hearts, living within you as you trust in him. May your roots go down deep into the soil of God’s marvelous love; 18-19 and may you be able to feel and understand, as all God’s children should, how long, how wide, how deep, and how high God’s love really is; and to experience this love for yourselves, though it is so great that you will never see the end of it or fully know or understand it. And so at last you will be filled up with God’s own self.